Property Brothers Reveal Their Most-Hated Paint Colors—And 3 They Love

The Property Brothers on the red carpet at an event
Debby Wong/Shutterstock
The product recommendations in this post are recommendations by the writer and/or expert(s) interviewed and do not contain affiliate links. Meaning: If you use these links to buy something, we will not earn a commission.

When it comes to making changes around the house, updating your paint choices can be a quick way to give everything a brand-new look or even boost your home's value. But while it may not be the same arduous undertaking as a gut renovation, getting it done right still takes plenty of skill—especially considering the number of choices available. Fortunately, home experts like HGTV stars Drew and Jonathan Scott have some pointers that can help make the decision process a little easier. Read on to see what the Property Brothers say are their most-hated paint colors and which ones they love.

RELATED: I'm a Dollar Tree Shopper and I Renovated My Kitchen for $30: "So Much Brighter."

The pair warns that one color could decrease the value of your home.

striped chair, side table with a plant, and two hanging lamps against gentle yellow wall
runna10/ iStock

We've all made interior design decisions we've come to regret, whether falling victim to overhyped trends or simply letting decor become dated. But in an episode of Property Brothers: Buying and Selling, Drew and Jonathan warn that these decisions could come back to haunt you when you put your home on the market.

While coaching a homeowner named Roseanne through a pre-sale renovation, the pair noted that the house's living room was still a creamy yellow hue, per Realtor.com. Unfortunately, this is now seen as something of a decor don't.

"Yellow walls don't really sell these days," Jonathan told her. He added that they would be budgeting to paint it a new color as part of the final project.

RELATED: Genius Small Bedroom Ideas to Maximize Space.

The two also despise the outdated look of more aggressive colors.

Male hand painting wall red with paint roller
iStock

But it wasn't just the pale-colored living room that stood out as a mistake to the two home experts. Upon further inspection, they noticed that some rooms were painted a deep red that comes across as aggressive—and even outdated.

Jonathan added the update to the list, saying they need to "get rid of that angry '90s red wall." In this case, the renovation team decided to do away with the wall entirely in favor of a more open-concept layout, per Realtor.com.

RELATED: How to Fix Insanely Boring Home Decor, According to an Interior Designer.

The Property Brothers tend to gravitate towards more minimal, comforting tones.

View of a modernist home office with dark gray walls and wood accents
Ground Picture / Shutterstock

While they're not fans of outdated color choices, Jonathan and Drew have some go-to options that can work in many situations. And the simplicity of their preferences might save you the frustration of having to test different swatches to find the perfect shade.

In a post to their website, the home renovation experts say they love a luxe-looking gray shade—or more specifically, Benjamin Moore's Chelsea Gray. They cite an episode of their show in which the color worked perfectly to update the look of kitchen cabinets and help them blend in with the rest of the home's main floor.

Jonathan also has a particular fondness for off-white in larger spaces. The Property Brother says he previously used the now-defunct Kelly Moore Cloud White in his projects, which has some hints of gray that help create texture. He also points out that this classic choice can help other features of your room, including fireplace masonry or wood accents, pop.

They also have a recommendation if you want some actual color on your walls.

A young, smiling woman paints her walls a sage green color.
MixMedia / iStock

Grays and whites make for a good simple approach, but there's still an argument for bringing color into your home. In this case, Drew says one of his top picks is a soft blue-green color that brings soothing elements with a tempered edge.

Scott landed on Benjamin Moore Grenada Villa during one of his renovations. And though he used it in a guest bedroom in that case, he also suggests that this would make for a great look in a kitchen or on a front door.

Zachary Mack Zach is a freelance writer specializing in beer, wine, food, spirits, and travel. He is based in Manhattan.Read moreFiled Under • Read This Next
  • LOS ANGELES - MAR 29: Drew Scott, Jonathan Scott at the 2015 iHeartRadio Music Awards at the Shrine Auditorium on March 29, 2015 in Los Angeles, CA

    8 Ways to Boost Your Home's Value

    The HGTV personalities open up about the improvements that can make a major difference.February 13, 2024
  • Drew and Jonathan Scott talking about home trends to avoid

    Property Brothers Warn Against 4 Home Trends

    The HGTV stars are speaking out about the fads they don't want you following.January 31, 2024
  • blue home with walkway through lawn

    5 Things That Devalue Your Home

    Eric Bramlett, owner of Bramlett Residential, shares his thoughts on key things that impact offers.October 2, 2023
  • joanna gaines

    Joanna Gaines Won't Use These Paint Colors

    Find out which shades are on the HGTV star's skip list.February 8, 2024
  • Modern living room with dark walls, beamed ceilings, and a contemporary fireplace

    "Moody" Paint Colors Increase Your Home's Value

    By choosing this color, you stand to gain thousands of dollars, according to a new Zillow study.July 12, 2023
  • An upset-looking man sitting on the floor with his head in his hands while surrounded by painting supplies

    The 10 Worst Paint Colors for Your Home

    They may affect your home's resale value, or they might just be plain unattractive.June 13, 2023
  • Viva magenta 2023 accent room. Luxury interior design with bright rich furniture. Gray black wall mockup. Burgundy maroon red deep armchair. Minimal interior design living lounge reception. 3d render

    The Unluckiest Paint Colors in Feng Shui

    There are better colors to use to attract good fortune.June 11, 2023
  • Couple renovating their apartment while man holding color palette and woman painting walls with roller.

    Paint Colors That Make Small Rooms Feel Bigger

    Designers and paint experts share their colorful tips for tricking the eye.May 24, 2023
  • 6 Paint Colors That Will Make You Happy

    Get happy by choosing one of these expert-approved paint colors.May 20, 2023
  • A young, smiling woman paints her walls a sage green color.

    5 Paint Colors to Brighten Low-Light Rooms

    These shades are sure to add light to even the darkest of spaces.May 14, 2023

You Might Also Like